Principles and Practices of Software Development

In this paper, we aim to provide a new perspective on the methods of software development. We find most software development methodologies to be overly prescriptive; they focus primarily on what methods to use without adequate consideration of what problems are being addressed and without a comparison of different methods that apply to the same problem. We maintain that software developers can be most effective if they are provided both with a variety of methods from which to choose and with the understanding necessary to select the methods that are best suited to their project. To that end, we introduce a framework for describing the principles of software development, a vocabulary for characterizing and understanding the constraints under which software is being written. We present some principles of software development, relating them to specific problems that occur in software projects and to practices that are used to address those problems. We observe that the practices of different methodologies can be understood in terms of how they weigh the relative importance of the underlying principles. We illustrate how identifying such principles can help in selecting the most appropriate practices. We note that some of the most significant differences among methodologies arise when principles provide conflicting viewpoints. We then discuss how iterative or incremental software development practices can be used to minimize the risks that result from conflicting principles. DRAFT of August 26, 2002 2